1) Prologue (Anna Lauris Joshua M. Bott Loretta Deranleau Howard)
2) Sorting Out the Sounds of Christmas (Ensemble (Listed Below) Eric Jensen
3) I've Gotta Provide (Jason Collins)
4) Fa-La-La (David Long Jason Collins)
5) Something About Christmas (David Long Eric Jensen)
6) What Would It Take? (Loretta Deranleau Howard Eric Jensen)
7) Where's the Evidence (Eric Jensen)
8) Just Another Day in Hell (David Austin Tracy Coe Loretta Deranleau Howard Stacie Hart)
9) Winds of Christmas (Joshua M. Bott)
10) Should You Forget Me (Katie Tomlinson)
11) The Fezziwig Ball (David-Edward Hughes Stacie Hart Anna Lauris David Austin Eric Jensen Katie Tomlinson Ensemble)
12) Bella's Chance (Anna Lauris)
13) Ev'ry Penny Counts/Act I Finale (David Austin Ernest Palmer Eric Jensen Joshua M. Bott Ensemble)
14) Where's the Evidence? Reprise (Eric Jensen)
15) What a Wonder Is a Life (Loretta Deranleau Howard Ensemble Eric Jensen)
16) By Jove! (David Long Stacie Hart Anna Lauris Greg Michael Allen)
17) How Could I Miss You (David Long)
18) Simple Ways (Tracy Coe)
19) God Bless (Jason Collins Tracy Coe Katie Tomlinson Joshua M. Bott Jacqueline Kamm)
20) You Make Me Shine (Tracy Coe Jason Collins Jacqueline Kamm)
21) Alleluia (Ensemble)
22) Share and Share Alike (Erin Murphy Greg Michael Allen)
23) You Made Me Shine (Jason Collins)
24) Look at Us - Scrooge Trio (Jacqueline Kamm David Austin Eric Jensen)
25) One More Chance/Finale II (Eric Jensen Harry Turpin Anna Lauris Joshua M. Bott Loretta Deranleau Howard Jason Collins Tracy Coe Katie Tomlinson Jacqueline Kamm Ensemble