1) Colored Lights
2) Chief Cook and Bottle Washer
3) Don't 'Ah Ma' Me
4) Blue Crystal
5) Under the the Roller Coaster
6) Not Enough Magic
7) (I) Here's to the Rink /(II) We Can Make It
8) After All These Years
9) Angel's Rink and Social Centre
10) What Happened to the Old Days?
11) Finale Act I (Colored Lights Reprise)
12) The Apple Doesn't Fall
13) Marry Me
14) (I) We Can Make It (Reprise)/(II) Mrs. a
15) The Rink
16) Wallflower
17) All the Children in a Row
18) Coda