1) Sesame Street Christmas Overture - Sesame Street
2) We Wish You a Merry Christmas - Sesame Street
3) Medley: Deck the Halls/Jingle Bells/White Christmas/Winter Wonderland - Fran Brill Clifford Kevin Clash Jim Henson Loretta Long Bob McGrath Jerry Nelson Frank Oz Carroll Spinney Carroll Spinney
4) I Hate Christmas - Carroll Spinney
5) Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas - Jim Henson Frank Oz
6) Twelve Days of Christmas - Fran Brill Clifford Kevin Clash Jim Henson Jerry Nelson Frank Oz Marty Robinson Carroll Spinney
7) True Blue Miracle - Clifford Kevin Clash Bob McGrath
8) Medley: It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas/Silver... [Medley] - Company Loretta Long Bob McGrath Roscoe Orman Frank Oz Carroll Spinney
9) All I Want for Christmas (Is My Two Front Teeth) - Jerry Nelson
10) Christmas Pageant - Fran Brill Jim Henson Jerry Nelson Frank Oz
11) Keep Christmas with You (All Through the Year) - Fran Brill Clifford Kevin Clash Emilio Delgado Jim Henson Loretta Long Bob McGrath Roscoe Orman Carroll Spinney
12) We Wish You a Merry Christmas (Reprise) - Clifford Kevin Clash Carroll Spinney