1) Overture - Dew
2) Heaven on Their Minds - Michael Lorant
3) What's the Buzz - Amy Ray/Emily Sailers
4) Strange Thing Mystifying - Michael Lorant/Amy Ray
5) Everything's Alright - Emily Sailers/Michael Lorant/Amy Ray
6) This Jesus Must Die - Benjamin/Mike Mantone
7) Hosanna - Mike Mantone/Amy Reed
8) Simon Zealotes - Kelly Hogan
9) Poor Jerusalem - Amy Reed
10) Pilate's Dream - Gerard McHugh
11) The Temple - Amy Reed
12) Everything's Alright (Reprise) - Emily Saliers/Amy Reed
13) I Don't Know How to Love Him - Emily Saliers
14) Damned for All Time/Blood Money - Michael Lorant/Mike Mantione/Benjamin
15) The Last Supper - Michael Lorant/Amy Ray
16) Gethsemane (I Only Want to Say) - Amy Ray
17) The Arrest - Michael Lorant/Amy Ray/Matt Brown/Benjamin/Mike Mantione
18) Peter's Denial - Anne Richmond Boston/Matt Brown/Jeff Jensen/Bill Decker/Emily Sailers
19) Pilate and Christ - Gerard McHugh/Rob Gal/Amy Ray
20) King Herod's Song - Dave Clair
21) Judas' Death - Michael Lorant/Mike Mantione/Benjamin
22) Trial Before Pilate - Gerard McHugh/Benjamin/Amy Reed/Rob Gal
23) Superstar - Social Insanity
24) Crucifixion - Amy Reed
25) John 19:41 - Revelation String Quartet