1) Mister Make Me a Song
2) How Marvin Eats His Breakfast
3) The Music Still Plays on
4) Republicans
5) I'd Rather Be Sailing
6) Hitchhiking Across America
7) That's Enough for Me
8) And They're Off
9) Anytime
10) Falsettos at the East Milford Community Center (Finn ; Derosa's Spoken
11) The Baseball Game
12) The Bitch and the Madonna (Finn Welcomes Mary Testa ; Carolee Carmello)
13) All Fall Down
14) When the Earth Stopped Turning
15) Tannis Root (Bill ; Mary Discuss Parenting)
16) Set Those Sails
17) I Have Found
18) Infinite Joy
19) Stupid Things I Won't Do
20) Infinite Joy (Reprise)
21) Bows