1) Joy to the World - the Little Mermaid
2) Jolly Old St. Nicholas/Up on the Housetop - Grease
3) It Was Simple Then - Monty Python's Spamalot
4) My Gift - Mamma Mia
5) Drowsy on Christmas Day - the Drowsy Chaperone
6) Tracy Turnblad's Big Bad Holiday Rap - Hairspray
7) Angels We Have Heard on High - the Color Purple
8) O Come All Ye Faithful - Young Frankenstein
9) This Little Light of Mine - Rosie's Broadway Kids
10) Christmas Makes the Whole World Warmer - Legally Blonde
11) Hark! the Herald Angels Sing - the Broadway Boys
12) Following a Star - the Phantom of the Opera
13) Mary's Lullaby - Wicked 1st National Tour
14) The First Noel - the Lion King
15) 'Twas the Night Before the Spelling Bee - the 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
16) What Child Is This? - Spring Awakening
17) (At the) North Pole Global Warming Surfin' Party - Avenue Q
18) The Monotone Angel - Curtains
19) Dominick the Donkey - Jersey Boys
20) Two English Carols - Mary Poppins
21) Away in a Manger - Xanadu
22) The Innkeeper's Lament - Altar Boyz
23) Jingle Bells - Wicked
24) Deck the Halls - Robbin Hood
25) The Coventry Carol/God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - Naked Boys Singing
26) Alleluia - Chicago
27) Broadway Holiday - a Chorus Line
28) Go Tell It on the Mountain - Rent
29) The 12 Days of Christ-Miz - Les Miserables
30) O Holy Night - Julia Murney ; Max Von Essen